Obi-Wan Kenobi Lived Long Enough To Become the Villain

hello world!
| June 24, 2022

Obi-Wan Kenobi series just finished its six-episode highly-anticipated run on Disney+ with an intense and emotional lightsaber battle between a master Jedi and his padawan turned slayer of children, Darth Vader. Unfortunately, the series also provided some really problematic choices by our characters to make sure they ended up in a place that fits conically with Star Wars: A New Hope. Fans, like myself, probably had some unrealistic expectations for this series that brought back Ewan McGregor to play Kenobi (who arguably was probably the best character other than Palpatine in the prequel films). We all dreamed of what a rematch would be like between Kenobi and Vader that wasn’t filmed in 1977. Vader, who at this point in time has had 10+ years under Palpatine learning the ways of the Darkside of the force versus Kenobi who some fans consider the wisest and greatest Jedi Master next to Yoda. The pieces are there for the first prestige Star Wars TV series. A series that would put Star Wars back in the same conversation as shows like Breaking Bad, Mad Men, or Battlestar Galactica. It seems like Disney’s writers had other plans and we have yet another good but not great Star Wars show. Let’s take a closer at some of the bad character decisions that dragged the series down and ultimately made Obi-wan liable for lots of suffering in a galaxy far away.

By just walking away and letting Vader live, Kenobi is liable for everything Darth Vader has done post this moment. That’s a lot of blood on Kenobi’s hands.

Obi-Wan’s to blame for lots of death

Let’s call out the big one right away. Obi-Wan in the finale after a pretty thrilling lightsaber fight has Vader beaten. Vader doesn’t seem keen on being redeemed (because we know only Luke can do that), instead, he’s all rage and says “I will destroy you!” igniting his lightsaber willing to continue the fight and probably die. Kenobi, in his Kenobi-like way, says “goodbye Darth.” and just walks away leaving Vader to live to continue to terrorize the galaxy and probably murder many more Jedi and innocent people. There’s really no good reason why Kenobi should let Vader live other than “well, he has to because future plot from the movies”. Obi-wan has seen what Vader is capable of in an earlier episode where he literally drags innocent people out of their homes and force chokes them to death. Let’s not forget to mention that Obi-wan is fully aware that Anakin killed all those children in the Jedi Temple. Darth Vader is a sith and Jedi kill sith. “But…but…Kenobi loved Anakin like a brother he couldn’t kill him!” some of you are screaming at me right now. Let me remind you all that Kenobi literally cut off Anakin’s legs and arm and left him to burn to death by lava in Revenge of the Sith. Not a very brotherly thing to do. Why not have some moment happen where Vader gets buried under rocks and Obi-wan thinks he’s dead and leaves. By just walking away and letting Vader live, Kenobi is liable for everything Darth Vader has done post this moment. That’s a lot of blood on Kenobi’s hands.

Other honorable mention bad decisions that Kenobi makes

Handing Haja (Kumail Nanjiani) a data recorder with information about the importance of Leia and Luke and their location. Is there not a delete message button? It was a bonehead move and felt like a lazy way to get Reva to Tatooine.

Leaving Leia and Tala in the tunnels to go fight Vader. It’s not like Vader or anyone was on to them yet. Instead of hanging around to watch Vader kill a bunch of people that Kenobi didn’t do anything to prevent anyways they could’ve all been halfway to the shuttle and off planet. Instead Kenobi gets the shit beat out of him by Vader and Leia gets kidnapped. Dumbass.

Not even attempting to use the force to mind trick the Storm Troopers at the checkpoint to let them go. A simple “you don’t need to see our credentials…let us pass” would’ve prevented a lot of issues moving forward. Also would’ve been a nice call back to A New Hope.


I guess impaling someone with a lightsaber doesn’t mean you die anymore in Star Wars.

Reva Had her shot and blew it

Reva and Obi-wan actually had a decent plan to distract Vader so Reva could kill him. But like all badly written scenes of course Reva waits till Vader is done focusing all his energy using his force pull to bring the rebel ship back down before attempting to strike him down. He rolled a 20 and force blocks that lazy swing of her’s and it’s all over for her. Everyone knows you strike when they least expect it.

Reva and Vader have the same problem killing Inquisitors

I guess impaling someone with a lightsaber doesn’t mean you die anymore in Star Wars. Can someone check on Qui gon? He might have survived that stab to the gut by Darth Maul after all based on the rules in this series. Both the Grand Inquisitor and Reva take what should be fatal lightsaber impalings in the gut/chest but yet both seem to carry on. The Grand Inquisitor chalks it up to using revenge as a motivation to stay alive after Reva surprise impaled him in episode 2. I guess Reva did the same thing after that plot point was given to her verbally by the Grand Inquisitor in front of Vader. That’s akin to when the villain describes his evil plan to the good guy right before he’s about to kill him but uses that knowledge to escape and win the day. Vader should’ve known better and decapitated her like Count Dooku. Why let your enemies live…twice. Oh yeah, so we can get the spin-off Reva show!

Also on a side note – how the hell did Reva get off that planet and to Tatooine so fast. Vader basically left her there to die. I doubt the Empire left a ship for her to in the off chance she lives and the only other ship in the hanger was the one Vader ripped apart. Did she call a galactic uber?

We obviously don’t need Star Wars to be perfect but we don’t need Star Wars to be smarter and give our characters smart decision-making skills that were properly foreshadowed or planned. This critique comes from love of all things Star Wars and in no way will this prevent me from watching all the future shows and rewatching Kenobi. As a fan I want Star Wars to be great and sometimes I feel as if it misses that mark but hey there’s always Andor right?!

What did you all think of Kenobi? Did any of the character decisions bother you? Did the show make you love Obi-wan as a character more or less? Will you be rooting for the sequel to happen? Let me know in the comments.


Share This

2 comments on “Obi-Wan Kenobi Lived Long Enough To Become the Villain”

  1. They never fully hurdled the obstacle of the audience knowing more than the characters for the entire show. We know how the OB1 story ends….. we know how the Vader/Anakin story ends……. we know how the Leia story ends….. most importantly, we know that all these stories resolve in an intertwined fashion decades down the road. “I didn’t know OB1 survived being thrown into fire…” my real-time reaction in the moment was already past tense. The entire show was a giant Pitch Meeting episode (“It’s gonna be really hard for them to get outta that mess…” “Actually, it’s gonna be super easy, barely an inconvenience.”). As soon as the story was set, ALL of the principals had insurmountable Plot Armor, and every single person in the audience knew that from Ep1 Sc1.

    That said there were some absolutely great moments – OB1 talking about his time as a Youngling; Reva’s rise up against Vader; the battle between OB1 and Anakin/Vader at the end – but there were also a lot more just plain silly things. Those highs were largely absent in BOBF, so OWK stands apart in that regard. But it’s a good bit well short of The Mandalorian. It has left me with mixed feels for the Ahsoka series, which is bothersome as Ahsoka is my favorite character, and Sabine Wren is my other favorite character. So I’m sort of at a crossroads here.

    1. The one good thing about Ashoka is we don’t really know how her story ends and we haven’t seen much of this era of her Journey. But at this point I just expect like all Disney+ shows that it will be good not great.

Comments are for members only. Sign up here to become a member for free.

Get our Newsletter!


Reviewing Reviews: Making Sense of the Madness

Are you struggling to make sense of review scores? Here are some great tips to help sift through the noise and find your truth within the chaos of review score aggregators! It’s just the thing you’ll need with The Game Awards and Oscars fast approaching.
by Iain McParlandNovember 22, 2023
1 2 3 681

Read more

The Return of Kenobi Review – Part IV

The Princess needs to be rescued! Will Obi-Wan be able to save her in time? Will he be strong enough to pull off this mission? What dark secrets does the Fortress Inquisitorius hold? Check out how Obi-Wan gets his groove back in Chapter IV.

More Real-Life Places That Inspired Pop Culture Phenomenons 

In part two of this ongoing series, Liza treks through even more real-world places that inspired some of the biggest franchises to hit pop culture.
1 2 3 112
© 2023 CouchSoup, LLC. All Rights Reserved
Terms of Service | Privacy
© 2022 CouchSoup, LLC. All Rights Reserved